A German silver flat pattern set, each instrument signed Richter with (mostly) DRP and the E O Richter monogram trade mark as well. The black leather covered case, blue velvet lined, has A G Thornton Ltd, Manchester on it. The Thornton Minerva series, introduced by 1916, were close copies of these Richter instruments, although the spring bow and pen designs were changed quite early in production (by 1922 or possibly earlier). This set probably dates from before the first world war.